Saturday, December 20, 2008

Unit test the class

Travis Griggs comes to the conclusion that unit test objects should map 1:1 to classes under test.

I agree.

In fact, I would go a bit further: tests should be an integral part of a class. While this helps avoid negative outcomes such as parallel class hierarchies or having code and tests diverge, it more importantly simplifies the test/code relationship and drives home the point that code is incomplete without its tests.

While I was working with JUnit on a reasonably large Java system, both finding a good place for a particular test and finding the tests for a specific class became quite burdensome after a while.

For this reason MPWTest simply asks classes to test themselves. Furthermore, only frameworks are tested, so the test tool simply loads each framework to test, enumerates the classes within that particular framework and then runs the tests it finds. TestCases and TestSuites are implicitly created from this structure, removing most of the administrative burdens of unit testing, and also any explicit dependence of the tests on the testing framework.

Having no dependencies on the testing framework makes it easier to ship tests in production code without having to also ship the testing framework. While this may sound odd at first, it avoids potential issues with code compiled for testing being different than code destined to be shipped, and further reinforces the idea that tests are an integral part of each class, rather than an optional add-on.

Labels: ,

3 Comments:

Blogger David said...

The link for MPWTest points to localhost. I'd like to see more about it.

December 21, 2008 7:37 PM  
Blogger Marcel Weiher said...

...which just goes to show that I should be unit-testing my blog entries.

The link has now been updated, but you will find that there isn't really any more information posted on the web about it. Have a look at the code (less than 500 LOC), or see it in action in Objective-XML or MPWFoundaiton. Or just ask me.

December 22, 2008 2:28 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Keep working ,great job!

December 26, 2009 6:41 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home